
Wednesday, March 28, 2007
The Daily Hump: Words of a Feather

petition [Online Etymology Dictionary]
pen [Online Etymology Dictionary]
fern [Online Etymology Dictionary]
penne [AHD]
Labels: Italian, Latin, Old English, PIE, The Daily Hump
:: posted by David, 8:03 AM
3 Comments:
The root you're refering to is, as of this century, reconstructed as *peth1-/*pth1- (with *h1, a glottal consonant). There is no such thing anymore as **pte-.
You happen to be citing Julius Pokorny's ancient reconstructions published long ago in the 1950s!
See http://www.bartleby.com/61/roots/IE405.html (But beware that American Heritage is also out-of-date by using a "schwa", a vowel, instead of a consonant "h" as found unanimously in modern academic texts. Blargh!! Makes me so mad!)
If interested in more geeky details about why we need to let go of Pokorny, check out my blog rant on the topic:
http://paleoglot.blogspot.com/2007/03/pokorny-lives-again.html
You happen to be citing Julius Pokorny's ancient reconstructions published long ago in the 1950s!
See http://www.bartleby.com/61/roots/IE405.html (But beware that American Heritage is also out-of-date by using a "schwa", a vowel, instead of a consonant "h" as found unanimously in modern academic texts. Blargh!! Makes me so mad!)
If interested in more geeky details about why we need to let go of Pokorny, check out my blog rant on the topic:
http://paleoglot.blogspot.com/2007/03/pokorny-lives-again.html
Awesome. Thanks so much for the correction and the Pokorny info. Let this be a lesson for you all: be wary of my armchair etymology.
Please forgive me as this has nothing to do with your current topic, but I was hoping I might get your help finding a word...
Suppose I have a leaky faucet. I go to find a wrench, but it's missing. I head for the car to visit the hardware store, but I have a flat tire. And so on. Is there a word that describes when you go down one path after another, ever further from where you started out?
much thanks,
Gary Stark
Suppose I have a leaky faucet. I go to find a wrench, but it's missing. I head for the car to visit the hardware store, but I have a flat tire. And so on. Is there a word that describes when you go down one path after another, ever further from where you started out?
much thanks,
Gary Stark